What to Do When Your Insurance Company Only Wants to Pay for a Partial Repair

What to Do When Your Insurance Company Only Wants to Pay for a Partial Repair


Dealing with property damage is stressful enough, but when your insurance company only offers to pay for partial repairs, the frustration can become overwhelming. This is a common scenario that many property owners face, especially during property claims disputes. If you're in Orlando, FL, and find yourself in this situation, knowing your rights and how to respond is key to ensuring you get the full coverage you're entitled to.

This guide walks you through why insurance companies may propose partial repairs, common tactics they use, and actionable steps you can take to protect yourself and your property.

 

Why Do Insurance Companies Offer Partial Repairs?

When filing a property claim, you're likely expecting your insurance company to fully cover the damage. However, insurers often aim to minimize their payouts, which can lead to offers that only cover part of the necessary repairs. Here are some common reasons they provide partial repair options:

1. Cost-Saving Measures

Insurance companies are businesses and, like any other business, they aim to minimize expenses. Partial repairs often cost less than complete restorations, making them a tempting option for insurers trying to protect their bottom line.

2. Questionable Damage Assessment

The insurance adjuster assigned to your claim may not thoroughly evaluate the scope of the damage. If they determine that the damage is superficial or isolated, they might propose a partial repair instead of assessing the structural or underlying issues.

3. Policy Misinterpretation

Sometimes, insurers interpret the language in your policy in a way that justifies paying only for partial repairs. They may argue that specific damages aren't covered under your policy terms.

4. Denying Causation

One common tactic is disputing the cause of the damage. For example, an insurance provider in Orlando may argue that storm-related roof damage wasn't due to the hurricane itself but was caused by wear and tear, which is typically not covered by policies.

Understanding their reasoning sets the foundation for disputing their offer effectively.

 

Steps to Take When Facing a Partial Repair Offer

If your insurance company offers to pay only for partial repairs, don't panic. Follow these steps to fight for the full coverage you deserve.

Step 1: Review Your Insurance Policy

Start by thoroughly reviewing your insurance policy, paying close attention to the coverage terms and exclusions. Look for key phrases regarding repairs and restorations, such as "replace like for like" or "restore to pre-loss condition." These terms can provide grounds to challenge the insurance company’s offer.

  • Pro Tip: If you're unsure how to interpret your policy, consult with a property claims expert who can clarify your coverage.

Step 2: Document the Damage in Detail

Proper documentation is crucial when disputing a low repair offer. Take the following steps to strengthen your case:

  • Photograph Everything: Snap photos of the damage from multiple angles, including any visible structural issues or interior damage.
  • Keep Records: Save receipts, repair estimates, and any written correspondence with your insurer.
  • Request a Detailed Claim Report: Ask the insurance company for a comprehensive breakdown of their damage assessment.

Having robust documentation can help you argue that partial repairs will not adequately address the issue.

Step 3: Seek Independent Contractor Estimates

An insurer’s assessment isn’t always accurate. Bring in an independent contractor to evaluate the full extent of the damage. Their estimate can provide evidence to counter the insurer’s partial offer.

For example, if storm damage has compromised your roof in Orlando, a local licensed contractor can inspect it and provide a full report indicating why partial repairs would be inadequate. Ensure the contractor’s estimate includes:

  • A detailed description of the necessary repairs.
  • An explanation of why a partial repair would be insufficient.
  • Costs broken down clearly.

Step 4: Engage a Public Adjuster

Public adjusters work on your behalf—not the insurance company’s. They’re licensed professionals who can review your claim, assess the damage properly, and negotiate with the insurance company for a better settlement.

Public adjusters are especially valuable if you’re in Florida, where hurricane damage and complex property claims are common. Their expertise can make a dramatic difference in getting the payout you need to fully restore your property.

Step 5: Don’t Accept the First Offer

Insurance companies may pressure you to accept their initial settlement, but you’re not obligated to do so. Instead, respond in writing to reject the offer and support your position with:

  • Documentation from Step 2.
  • Estimates from Step 3.
  • A clear explanation of why partial repairs will not fully restore your property to its pre-loss condition.

Remember, agreeing to partial repairs could leave you footing the bill for recurring problems down the line.

Step 6: File a Complaint or Legal Action

If all else fails, consider filing a complaint with the Florida Department of Financial Services or seeking legal counsel. A property insurance attorney in Orlando, FL, can assess whether your insurer acted in bad faith by denying fair coverage.

While litigation should be a last resort, it’s a necessary step in cases where insurers refuse to negotiate in good faith.

 

Why You Should Fight for Full Repairs

Accepting partial repairs could have long-lasting consequences, including:

  • Recurring Problems: Partial fixes may not address the root cause of the damage, leading to future repairs and added costs.
  • Lower Property Value: Without complete repairs, your property’s market value could decrease.
  • Voided Warranties: Some materials and systems require full replacement to maintain warranty coverage.

By advocating for a proper settlement, you protect both the integrity and value of your property.

 

The Importance of Expert Help with Property Claims in Orlando, FL

Navigating property claims disputes is complicated, especially when your insurer is pushing for partial repairs. That’s why local expertise matters.

Florida’s unique weather patterns, including hurricanes and tropical storms, mean homeowners are particularly vulnerable to property damage. Having a team that understands these challenges and has experience working with insurers in Orlando, FL, can make all the difference.

Ultra Property Damage specializes in advocating for property owners to get the full coverage they deserve. From answering your questions to negotiating with insurance companies, we’re here to make the process as seamless as possible.

 

Here’s How We Can Help

If you need help with property claims in Orlando, FL, contact Ultra Property Damage today for a free consultation. Our experienced team is ready to fight for your rights and ensure your property is restored to its full condition.

Don’t settle for partial repairs. Your property deserves better, and so do you!

To Top